In this guide to the types of smokers, you’ll learn how each style works and which one fits your backyard cooking style.

What type of smoker should I buy?

Pellet? Offset? Charcoal? Electric? Drum?

They all cook low and slow.
They all use smoke.
But they behave very differently.

This guide breaks down the different types of smokers, how they work, who they’re best for, and what you can realistically expect from each. Whether you’re brand new or upgrading your setup, this will help you make the right decision.

---

Types of Smokers (Quick Comparison for Beginners)

A smoker is a cooking device that uses indirect heat and wood smoke to cook food at low temperatures — typically between 200°F and 275°F — over an extended period of time. When comparing types of smokers, the biggest differences come down to fuel type, temperature control, and how hands-on you want to be.

Unlike grilling (direct high heat), smoking is about:

• Temperature control
• Airflow management
• Fuel management
• Time and patience

Now let’s break down the major types.

---

1️⃣ Pellet Smokers (Set-It-and-Forget-It Control)

How Pellet Smokers Work

Pellet smokers burn compressed hardwood pellets. An auger feeds pellets into a burn pot, and a digital controller regulates temperature automatically.

Think of it as a wood-fired oven with thermostat control.

Best For:

• Beginners
• Busy cooks
• Overnight briskets
• Consistency-focused cooks

Pros:

• Very stable temperatures
• Easy to operate
• Great for long cooks (10+ hours)
• Excellent versatility (smoke, roast, bake)

Cons:

• Requires electricity
• Smoke flavor is lighter than stick burners
• Mechanical parts can fail over time

Flavor Profile:

Clean, mild wood smoke. You can intensify flavor using lower temps early in the cook.

Pellet smokers are often the easiest entry point into barbecue. If you’re looking for convenience without sacrificing quality, this category is hard to beat.

---

2️⃣ Offset Smokers (Traditional Stick Burners)

How Offset Smokers Work

An offset smoker has a firebox attached to the side of the main cooking chamber. You burn wood splits in the firebox, and heat + smoke travel across the meat before exiting the chimney.

This is traditional Texas-style barbecue equipment.

Best For:

• Traditionalists
• Fire managers
• Deep smoke flavor seekers

Pros:

• Rich, heavy smoke flavor
• No electricity needed
• True fire control

Cons:

• Steep learning curve
• Requires constant tending
• Fuel-intensive

Flavor Profile:

Deep, bold, complex smoke flavor.

Offset smokers require managing airflow and fuel manually. If you love fire management and hands-on cooking, this is the purest form of backyard smoking.

---

3️⃣ Charcoal Smokers (Kettle, Bullet & Kamado Style)

How Charcoal Smokers Work

Charcoal smokers use lump charcoal or briquettes as the primary heat source. Wood chunks are added for smoke flavor.

There are several styles:

• Kettle grills (used with indirect setup)
• Bullet smokers (vertical water smokers)
• Ceramic kamado cookers

Best For:

• Budget-friendly smoking
• Versatility (grill + smoke)
• Strong smoke flavor

Pros:

• Excellent flavor
• Affordable entry point
• No electricity needed
• Can sear and grill as well

Cons:

• Requires vent management
• Temperature control takes practice

Flavor Profile:

Stronger than pellet, lighter than offset (depending on wood use).

Charcoal smokers offer a balance between control and flavor intensity, making them one of the most versatile options available.

---

4️⃣ Electric Cabinet Smokers

How Electric Smokers Work

Electric smokers use a heating element to generate heat. Wood chips are added in a tray to create smoke.

You plug them in, set the temperature, and they maintain heat automatically.

Best For:

• Absolute beginners
• Apartment or limited space users
• Low-effort smoking

Pros:

• Easiest to operate
• Consistent temperature
• Affordable models available

Cons:

• Light smoke flavor
• Requires electricity
• Less traditional barbecue experience

Flavor Profile:

Mild smoke.

Electric smokers are a great way to learn timing and internal meat temperatures without the complexity of fire management.

---

5️⃣ Drum Smokers (UDS – Ugly Drum Smoker)

How Drum Smokers Work

Drum smokers are vertical barrel-style cookers that burn charcoal at the bottom with airflow entering from the base and exiting through top vents.

They are extremely efficient and surprisingly stable once dialed in.

Best For:

• Budget-conscious cooks
• DIY enthusiasts
• High heat efficiency

Pros:

• Excellent flavor
• Efficient fuel use
• Simple construction

Cons:

• Basic features
• Manual airflow control

Flavor Profile:

Bold charcoal-driven smoke.

Drum smokers are underrated workhorses that deliver serious barbecue flavor at a lower cost.

---

Pellet vs Offset vs Charcoal: Which Smoker Is Best?

There is no universal “best smoker.”

The right smoker depends on:

• How involved you want to be
• Your budget
• Available space
• Desired smoke intensity
• Comfort with fire management

If You Want:

• Maximum convenience → Pellet
• Traditional heavy smoke → Offset
• Versatility + value → Charcoal
• Simplicity → Electric
• Budget flavor machine → Drum

Each path produces excellent barbecue when used correctly.

---

What Beginners Should Consider Before Buying

Before choosing a smoker, ask yourself:

1. Do I want to manage fire manually?
2. Will I cook overnight briskets?
3. Do I have access to electricity?
4. How much space do I have?
5. What’s my realistic budget?

Buying the wrong style can lead to frustration — not because it’s bad equipment, but because it doesn’t match your cooking style.

---

Final Thoughts: The Best Type of Smoker Is the One You’ll Actually Use

The truth is this:

A well-managed charcoal kettle can outperform an expensive pellet grill.

A skilled offset cook can produce world-class brisket.

A beginner on an electric smoker can still turn out incredible ribs.

Equipment matters — but technique matters more.

No matter which type of smoker you choose, success comes down to:

• Controlling temperature
• Managing airflow
• Choosing the right wood
• Using accurate thermometers
• Understanding the stall and wrapping

Master those fundamentals and any smoker becomes a powerful tool. Once you understand the types of smokers, choosing the right one becomes less about hype and more about how you actually like to cook.